Friday 11 November 2011

Book Review: Silence by Becca Fitzpatrick.

Product details:
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children's Books
Hardcover, 438 pages.
Release date: October 4th 2011.
Rating: 2½ out of 5.
Ages: 14+
Series: Hush, Hush #3
Other books in series: Hush, Hush, Crescendo
Source: Received from publisher for review.

The noise between Patch and Nora is gone. They've overcome the secrets riddled in Patch's dark past...bridged two irreconcilable worlds...faced heart-wrenching tests of betrayal, loyalty and trust...and all for a love that will transcend the boundary between heaven and earth. Armed with nothing but their absolute faith in one another, Patch and Nora enter a desperate fight to stop a villain who holds the power to shatter everything they've worked for—and their love—forever.

 Please note: This review may contain spoilers for previous books in the series.

Fast-Paced and exciting with multiple plot twists and a crazy cliffhanger ending that left me wanting more, Becca Fitzpatrick’s Crescendo was a firm favourite of mine in 2010, and because of this, I had very high expectations for the third in the Hush, Hush sequence, Silence, which I had believed would be the series finale. Of course, it’s not. Shortly before the release of Silence, a fourth addition to the series was announced. I’m mentioning this because, along with a lot of other readers I was all set for epic final showdowns, more action, more suspense, more plot twists, and more romance than ever before in this book. But since it’s not the series finale, Silence doesn’t really have any of that. For me Silence was sometimes slow moving, slightly disappointing and often frustrating read that lacked the intensity of its predecessors.

I’ve already mentioned the almighty cliffhanger that occurred in the final pages of Crescendo. It left me wide-eyed in disbelief and I wanted more. I know some of you hated it. I loved it, but no matter how much we disagree on the inclusion of that particular cliffhanger, I think we’ll all agree that we wanted Silence to pick right up where Crescendo left off. It doesn’t. We wanted to find out what happened next. We don’t. Instead the plot picks up three months on from the events of that fateful night. In that time, Nora has been missing, but as we join the action she is making her way back home. Patch is nowhere to be seen, a fact that Nora doesn’t question, because she doesn’t remember him. She has no recollection of Patch or of anything else that has happened in the time since they first met.  The doctors say its amnesia, but we know that there are far more sinister means at work, and it’s up to Nora to unlock the secrets that are hidden deep inside her mind.

Here’s my major problem with the direction taken by Fitzpatrick in Silence. Nora doesn’t remember anything that’s happened since she first met Patch, but we do. As readers, we are always ten steps ahead of her in this book. This makes for frustrating reading, because Nora takes her sweet time in remembering certain things, her hot fallen angel boyfriend being one of the most important of those things.

 For me, Patch brings the same magic to the Hush, Hush series that Edward brought to Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight, and when Patch isn’t around everything is a little duller, a little less exciting, especially since, just like Bella Swan before her, Nora is not the most likeable character at times. Remember when Edward disappeared from the pages of New Moon? Didn’t you skip ahead to see when he returned? I had a similar urge here to skip ahead and find out when Patch would show up. He simply doesn’t appear in Silence often enough. When he does though, he has all the best lines, and he is as divine as ever. In fact, he is hotter than ever before, so why so little of him?

While Patch isn’t in Nora’s life like he was before, Scott makes reappearance and is here presented as a laid back, playful and flirtatious guy. In other words, nothing like the Scott I remember from Crescendo. As Scott isn’t a character that made any great impression on me in Crescendo I could be wrong in this assumption, but he seemed like a completely different character from the sullen, secretive guy in the previous book. Marcie Millar wasn’t her same old self in this book either, and her snarky mean girl attitude and constant bitchiness was something I actually missed from this book.  In Crescendo Marcie was a character I loved to hate, but in Silence she’s just forgettable.

In conclusion, I can’t help but think that Silence suffered due to the addition of another book to this series.  It is plot-weak at times especially when you consider that a large chunk of the book consists of Nora remembering what happened in previous books. Considering that I already knew what Nora had forgotten, that element of the story did not work for me at all. I wanted action, and I wanted Patch. I really wanted to love Silence. While this one is my least favourite book in the series, it’s not all bad. It contains some hot Patch scenes that are hotter than ever before, and it does at least set the scene for that epic final showdown I have been waiting for. Hopefully the next book will contain a whole lot more of Patch, because this series just isn’t the same when he’s not around.


  1. I am so disappointed that Patch isn't in Silence a bit more. I LOVED Crescendo and was excited for the final showdown you are referring to in SIlence; that stinks that they added another book. And I can't believe Marcie is forgettable in Silence- I couldn't stand her in Crescendo! Anyway, I'm sorry that you were disappointed. This seems like one of those middle of the series kind of reads. Thanks for the great review though!

  2. I wasn't really impressed with Hush, Hush - and while I have planned on reading Crescendo, I'm in no hurry. Silence doesn't sound like my kind of book - I would totally get frustrated always being ten steps ahead of Nora. I think I'll wait and see how the last book turns out before coming back to this series. Sorry you were disappointed with it - thanks for the great review! :).

  3. Aw, I'm sorry it didn't turn out to be as good as you expected. I would get so frustrated if I remembered an entire history that the MC didn't, yet, I still had to wait for her to discover it.

    I haven't read this series yet, but I am considering giving it a try. Thanks for your review!

  4. Hmm, doesn't sound so promising does it. I bought it but haven't read it yet. Still trying to decide whether to bother. Thanks for your review.

  5. Thanks for the honest review! I've been hedging on whether to read this series or not, and now I think I'll just hold off for now. It kinda sounds like Nora doesn't show much in the way of character development without her boyfriend around, which was the same flaw I found in Bella. I kinda hate it when a female protag is so dependent on the males in her life that she has no personality or character strength, and nor does she get stronger or develop more on her own--she just remains a weak, passive, "rescue me" plot device, not a character.

    ...and, rant off! ;)


  6. This sounds like a frustrating read. It almost reminds me of watching a horror film and shouting "he's behind you!!" at the heroine. It's a shame when something otherwise promising is dragged out unnecessarily.


Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment. I really appreciate it!

If you are a book blogger and have taken the time to comment, I will make sure to come visit your blog and return the favour. :)

Please note: This blog is now an award free zone. Thanks to everyone who has awarded the blog in the past.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Related Posts with Thumbnails View My Stats